The Gallup Poll and the Door: What 1938 America and 2026 America Share.

In 2001, on 911 my mother told me I was Jewish. No one in my immediate family is comfortable with that fact. Everyone who has tested has Jewish DNA. And more than that, many are Cohens, the priestly line from Aaron, the brother of Moses.

She had carried that secret for decades — hidden practices, Ladino phrases, a family line running from Spain through Mexico into Texas and New Mexico. Crypto-Jewish. Halevi. My maternal grandfather carried Cohen DNA, the priestly line J-FT235823, with roots tracing through Iberia, Portugal, Germany, and New Spain since the 1500’s.

I was raised Christian. Altar boy at seven. I spent sixteen years trying to make the Christian Bible fit the Hebrew Bible before I finally admitted they do not fit. They are incompatible texts with incompatible claims.

In 2017, I returned to Judaism. I converted. Our congregation at the time, Mayim Chaim Ministries in Amarillo, Texas, had eighty to a hundred Messianic believers on a Friday or Saturday night. Today it is two.

Two Jews. Eight years. Doors open. In a city of over two hundred thousand people, no Christian friend has called to ask how we are doing — and the ones who do go silent the moment I say I do not believe in Jesus.

This is not a complaint. It is a data point. And it matches a pattern America has seen before.

Antisemitic USA

What the Polls Said in 1938

The podcast The Diaspora Files lays out the record with uncomfortable precision. Gallup and other polling organizations in the late 1930s found that large majorities of Americans disapproved of Nazi persecution of Jews. That sounds noble until you read the second set of numbers: majorities also opposed taking in Jewish refugees.

After Kristallnacht in November 1938, when synagogues burned across Germany and tens of thousands of Jews were sent to concentration camps, American public opinion still rejected proposals to admit refugee children. The Wagner-Rogers Bill, which would have brought twenty thousand Jewish children to safety, died in Congress.

Significant shares of Americans, in those same polls, blamed Jews in part for their own troubles. Jews were accused of having too much power in finance and media. Hotels posted “restricted” signs. Universities enforced quotas. This was not fringe behavior. It was the mainstream American consensus, held by churchgoing, flag-waving, self-described decent people.

The same country that condemned the persecution refused the persecuted.

The Righteous Among the Nations

But that is not the whole story, and the podcast is honest about it.

On February 20, 1939, twenty thousand Americans packed Madison Square Garden for a pro-Nazi rally organized by the German American Bund. Outside, over 100,000 New Yorkers protested. Varian Fry smuggled artists and intellectuals out of occupied France. The Sharps, a Unitarian minister and his wife, drove into Nazi territory to rescue Jews. The Four Chaplains — two Protestants, one Catholic, one Jewish — gave their life jackets to others when their troopship was torpedoed in 1943 and went down with the ship, arm in arm, praying.

And there is Roddie Edmonds.

A master sergeant from Knoxville, Tennessee, was captured in the Battle of the Bulge and held at Stalag IX-A in Germany. In January 1945, the camp commandant ordered all Jewish prisoners to step forward. Edmonds, a devout Baptist, ordered every man in his barracks to step forward — hundreds of soldiers. When the German officer demanded to know which ones were Jewish, Edmonds replied: “We are all Jews here.”

The commandant drew his pistol. Edmonds did not move. The officer backed down. Edmonds saved over two hundred Jewish lives that day. In 2015, Yad Vashem named him Righteous Among the Nations — the first American soldier so honored.

That is the floor. Not the ceiling. The floor. If your standard is “we are all Jews here,” then everything above it is optional, and everything below it is the problem.

2026: The Same Split, New Clothes

Fast forward to today. The ADL’s 2025 audit recorded 6,274 antisemitic incidents in the United States — the third-highest year on record since 1979, still far above pre-2023 baselines, with physical assaults and attacks involving deadly weapons at record levels. Gallup tracking shows favorable views of Israel have fallen into the mid-forties to mid-fifties, with Democrats majority-unfavorable for the first time in their long series, and younger Americans more negative still.

The old tropes have not died. Dual loyalty. Too much power. Jews are bringing trouble on themselves. They now circulate through both far-right conspiracy channels and far-left anti-Zionism that slides, with depressing regularity, into the same medieval accusations wearing modern vocabulary.

And my Christian friends — the ones I interview, the ones I have known for years — they all say the same thing. I disagree with what’s happening to the Jews. I condemn the hatred. And then, when the conversation turns personal, when the question becomes Would you have us here, in your town, in your church, at your table — the silence. Not hostility. Silence. Which is somehow worse, because hostility at least acknowledges you exist.

The Question That Matters

Here is what I have learned from eight years of two people in a sanctuary built for a hundred: opposition in the abstract is not the same as welcome in the particular. America in 1938 proved it. America in 2026 is proving it again.

The Gallup poll was never the test. The door was the test. Roddie Edmonds did not answer a survey. He stood between his men and the rifle.

So this is my question, and I am asking it to every American who reads this, Christian or not: Would you have taken us in?

This question is not “America.” Not “the church.” Not “history will judge.” You. This is on your street. Your congregation. Your Thanksgiving table.

Because the people who stood up in 1939 — the hundred thousand outside Madison Square Garden, the Fryes and the Sharps, the Four Chaplains, Sergeant Edmonds — they were not a majority. They were never a majority. They were the ones who understood that condemning evil from a safe distance costs nothing, and that the only thing that has ever mattered is whether the door opens.

Footnotes

  1. The Diaspora Files, YouTube, YouTube.be/OPjXXn1n6SQ — Gallup polling on American attitudes toward Nazi persecution and Jewish refugees, 1938–1945, including post-Kristallnacht refugee opposition and the Wagner-Rogers Bill.
  2. Gallup historical polls, 1938–1941. See also David S. Wyman, Paper Walls: America and the Refugee Crisis, 1938–1941 (1968).
  3. Wagner-Rogers Bill (1939): proposed admission of 20,000 German Jewish children; died in committee. Congressional Record, 76th Congress.
  4. Yad Vashem, Righteous Among the Nations: Roddie Edmonds, honored 2015. Stalag IX-A, January 1945, approximately 200 Jewish POWs saved. yadvashem.org/righteous.html
  5. ADL Audit of Antisemitic Incidents, 2025: 6,274 incidents, third-highest since 1979. adl.org/resources/report/audit-antisemitic-incidents-2025
  6. Gallup, “Views of Israel” trend data, 2023–2026.
  7. Crypto-Jewish heritage, American Southwest: Schulamith Halevy; J-FT235823 Cohen Modal Lineage marker; 23andMe and FamilyTreeDNA results.
  8. Incompatibility of Christian and Hebrew biblical theology: author’s Star of Jacob series and beithashoavah.org.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.